Evolution Letters

In most species, unmated individuals run the risk of dying with zero fitness. This strong selection on virgin females to mate may also explain why females subsequently remate, despite fitness costs; all that is required is a genetic correlation between virgin and non-virgin mating propensity. Despite being the null model for the evolution and maintenance of polyandry, this hypothesis has received no empirical test. We performed separate quantitative genetic and artificial selection experiments to test the presence of this cross-context genetic correlation in the cow-pea weevil, Callosobruchus maculatus. A quantitative genetic experiment did not find evidence of the hypothesised genetic correlation. However, after 13 generations of artificial selection on virgin mating latency, we found strong evidence for evolutionary divergence in remating latency. Females from lines selected for longer virgin mating latency took approximately twice as long to remate and, were less polyandrous if their virgin mating latency was longer. There was no evidence that females could mate indiscriminately and then trade-up, rather, trading up could only occur if virgin discrimination was present. Selection against virgin death will thus constrain both the evolution of non-virgin discrimination and trading up, increasing rates of polyandry. These findings reveal a genetic correlation between virgin and non-virgin latency to mate suggesting that polyandry may be maintained because of the need to breed.

Organisms have evolved a remarkable diversity of reproductive strategies in response to environmental variations and selective pressures. Although most vertebrates do reproduce biparentally, rare alternative modes such as selfing (self-fertilization) and different forms of parthenogenesis exist, but remain poorly characterized. Here, we investigated an unusual reproductive event in the normally biparental cichlid fish Cyphotilapia frontosa, in which a female produced offspring in the absence of a male. Using whole-genome sequencing data, we analyzed whether reproduction occurred via selfing or parthenogenesis by comparing patterns of heterozygosity with those from a wild, genetically diverse C. frontosa family collected in Lake Tanganyika and a closely related inbred Ctenochromis benthicola family. The uniparental family exhibited reduced genetic diversity, elevated relatedness, and genome-wide patterns of homozygosity distinct from those expected under parthenogenesis or inbreeding, but consistent with self-fertilization. Our study provides rare genomic evidence of selfing in a vertebrate and suggests that such alternative reproductive modes may be overlooked rather than truly absent. These findings contribute to a broader understanding of how alternative reproductive strategies evolve in vertebrate lineages. SignificanceThe overwhelming majority of vertebrates reproduce sexually, requiring a male and a female to produce genetically distinct offspring. Yet, rare alternative modes involving only a single parent such as asexual parthenogenesis ("virgin birth") or self-fertilization challenge this paradigm. Among these, selfing is exceptionally uncommon and poorly studied in vertebrates. Here, we unveiled - based on genomic analyses - the reproductive strategy of a member of the extraordinarily diverse cichlid fish radiation in Lake Tanganyika that reproduced in captivity in the absence of a male. By comparing patterns of genome-wide heterozygosity with both wild and inbred reference families, we identified a rare case of selfing. This finding adds to the limited records of selfing in vertebrates and expands current understanding of reproductive diversity, highlighting the power of whole-genome sequencing to distinguish among alternative reproductive mechanisms.

Adaptive phenotypic plasticity can bolster fitness in changing environments, but the extent to which plasticity evolves rapidly, and which forces shape this evolutionary trajectory, is largely unknown. To empirically study the evolution of plasticity we first conducted a replicated field experiment in which Drosophila melanogaster populations adapted to insecticide exposure and a subset of these populations received high diversity assisted gene flow. We then reared individuals from each population across temperature and insecticide treatments in common garden to test the following questions: 1. Has prior selection and rapid adaptation of insecticide resistance led to evolved shifts in plasticity relative to naive populations? 2. Does gene flow from genetically diverse populations contribute to adaptive plasticity evolution relative to gene flow-restricted low diversity populations? Both gene flow and prior evolution of resistance influenced the evolution of plasticity for multiple traits and were often maladaptive for resistant and gene flow-restricted populations, suggesting a trade-off between trait and plasticity evolution. Assisted gene flow minimized maladaptive plasticity potentially through relaxation of underlying epistatic or pleiotropic constraints. Together, these results demonstrate the dynamic interactions between trait evolution, the evolution of plasticity, and forces that shape genetic diversity with implications for conservation of threatened populations.

The evolution of alternative male reproductive strategies represents an intriguing evolutionary phenomenon. Divergent strategies are persistently at risk of local extinction or invasion, depending on the suites of traits expressed within and between morphs; hence, understanding the correlational selection that aligns reproductive strategies with behaviour, morphology and physiology is key to understanding the origin and maintenance of genetic polymorphisms. In the polychromatic painted dragon, Ctenophorus pictus, yellow, orange and red morphs are well characterised, but the blue morph has been historically absent from studied populations. Here we document the local distribution, morphology and male-contest interactions in a population where blue males are relatively common. We find that blue males express head colouration after a reaching a threshold body size, and that small blue males can reside in close proximity to other males; patterns consistent with a novel size-dependent conditional tactic within the suite of genetic strategies seen in this species. Condition-dependent, positively allometric throat bibs were non-randomly distributed among male morphs, implicating variation in correlational selection and the genetic architecture of the polymorphism. We were unable to definitively assign a morph that was superior in male competition but found that within morphs, male size was the determinant of competitive success, whilst between morphs it was not. Furthermore, contests between morphs were resolved with less aggression than contests within morphs, supporting the idea that badges resolve conflict, and that the invasion of new colour morphs may be facilitated by negative frequency dependent benefits to novel colour variants. These findings highlight the divergent phenotypic, genetic and selective environments that lead to the diversity of colour morphs.

In androdioecious species like Caenorhabditis elegans, where the primary mode of reproduction is self-fertilization, the evolutionary role of males has long puzzled biologists. One proposed benefit of males is the potential to escape inbreeding depression. We tested this by enforcing seven generations of inbreeding across nine C. elegans strains differing in baseline male frequency and measuring competitive relative fitness before and after inbreeding. We then relaxed inbreeding for four generations to assess recovery. We predicted that strains with higher male frequency, and greater opportunity for outcrossing, would exhibit faster recovery once inbreeding was relaxed. Strains varied substantially in their responses with most showing significant fitness declines and partial recovery but neither the magnitude of inbreeding depression nor the extent of recovery correlated with male frequency. These results show that male frequency is a poor predictor of inbreeding responses and does not reliably reflect realized outcrossing or its fitness consequences.

Intralocus sexual conflict (IaSC) results from opposing selection acting on traits with correlated expression between the sexes. We recently reported on a male-limited (ML) selection experiment in Drosophila melanogaster designed to investigate IaSC through a sex-limited evolution regime that theoretically resolves conflict in favour of males. However, this experiment did not universally or unambiguously improve male fitness, although female fitness declined as predicted. Here we examine sources of unintended selection: unusual genetic features of the breeding design and the special females used to enforce male-limited inheritance that may have complicated evolutionary outcomes. Specifically, we evaluate the effects of a foreign cytoplasm, genetically marked translocated autosomes, and a female-exposed Y chromosome derived from the clone-generator (CG) system, and the unique environment of sexual selection introduced by foreign CG females. We found that selected male fitness increased by 66% when expressed within the full ML genetic context, rising to over 100% when interacting with CG females. While there is no consistent fitness advantage in the "wild type" genetic background, there is a nearly significant trend of improved fitness with CG females (26% improvement). Further, outside this context, these males do not experience a fitness loss relative to controls, even showing a marginal gain of 6%. Uniformly, these gains were mediated by precopulatory traits: ML selection produced more attractive males with greater mating success and shorter mating latencies, while sperm competition remained unchanged. Intriguingly, ML-evolved males also exhibited reduced mate harm to females, contrary to the established narrative of escalating intersexual antagonism in this system. Dissecting individual components revealed significant fitness improvements associated with adaptation to the foreign cytotype (18%) and the female-exposed Y chromosome (33%), although responses varied across replicate populations. Moreover, when selected haplotypes were expressed together with the foreign cytotype in females, we observe a recovery in fitness. Together, these findings demonstrate extensive compensatory evolution to the ML selection environment, indicating that responses to the release of IaSC were shaped not only by sexually antagonistic selection but also by adaptation to the genetic manipulations and mating context inherent to the experimental design.

The breakdown of distyly, a polymorphism that promotes disassortative pollination between two floral morphs, has significant evolutionary implications. Here we examine the consequences of repeated loss of distyly in Linum by testing for relaxed selective pressure in homostylous relative to distylous lineages, and by characterising the evolutionary genomic patterns of the homostylous Linum leonii in comparison to its distylous close relative Linum perenne. We generated whole-genome sequences and target-capture data from sixteen Linum species, and additionally built a high-quality genome assembly and acquired population-level whole-genome sequencing data for L. leonii (n=20). We reconstructed plastome and nuclear phylogenies, estimated selective pressure for chloroplast and nuclear genes, inferred ancestral floral morph states, and tested for signatures of selfing in L. leonii. Compared to theoretical expectations, results were mixed, with partial identification of relaxed selective pressure in homostyles. One clade exhibited signs of potentially accelerated plastome evolution. Population genomic analyses of L. leonii revealed a moderate selfing rate of 0.32, suggesting that loss of distyly was associated with mixed mating rather than selfing, contrary to previous results on loss of distyly. Reduced nucleotide diversity and evidence for relaxed selection efficacy in L. leonii was likely due to a historical bottleneck. These results highlight the complex evolutionary dynamics associated with the breakdown of distyly. The genomic consequences are more heterogeneous than previously thought, and likely depend on clade- and species-specific evolutionary and demographic history dynamics. This study emphasizes the need for comparative population genomic studies to clarify how such transitions can shape evolutionary processes. Significance statementPlant mating system variation is central to evolution as it shapes genetic diversity, adaptability and fitness. Loss of distyly, an iconic example of a complex mating system favouring cross-pollination, can drives shift from outcrossing to selfing, with potentially severe evolutionary consequences for the long-term persistence of the species in which it occurs. Using high-quality genome assembly and omic data for multiple Linum species, we tested for relaxed selective pressure following loss of distyly in homostylous species and tested for a signature of selfing in homostylous Linum leonii compared to the closely related distylous Linum perenne. Contrary to theoretical expectations, evidence for relaxation of selection was mixed in Linum homostyles and L. leonii did not exhibit a genomic signature of selfing. Our study reveals multiple evolutionary pathways following the loss of distyly, and highlights how mating system transitions, together with complex demographic processes, can differentially shape plant genetic diversity and evolution.

The phenotypic effects of mutations often depend on the genetic background, yet general patterns remain poorly resolved. Here, we tested whether genotypes drawn from the same natural population, but differing in their breeding values for a polygenic trait, differed in their contribution of new mutational variation to that trait. We established >200 mutation-accumulation (MA) lines from four Drosophila serrata genotypes. Analysing >44,000 wing-size measurements, collected over 30 generations, we quantified mutational variance and mutational bias for size. Genotypes with the smallest and largest breeding values for size contributed similar (statistically indistinguishable) amounts of mutational variance. In contrast, the genotype with an intermediate breeding value exhibited remarkably low (statistically undetectable) mutational variance, low micro-environmental variance, and high line survival over time, consistent with limited mutational decay in fitness. The three genotypes with detectable mutational input showed declines in mean size over time, indicating a consistent mutational bias toward smaller size, as reported in other taxa. The magnitude of this bias appeared genotype dependent, with the MA populations founded from the larger ancestors declining nearly twice as fast as that founded from the smallest ancestor. Together, these results demonstrate substantial heterogeneity in mutational properties among genotypes within a single natural population where the trait value spans a relatively narrow range. Such genotype-specific mutational input is expected to shape both the standing genetic variance and the evolutionary trajectory of polygenic traits.

The evolution of plant resistance naturally occurs in complex, multifaceted environments that consist of multiple simultaneous stressors. Understanding how shifting environmental contexts may shape resistance evolution requires empirical studies that consider the combined effects of interacting stressors on fitness and selection. Here, we examined how exposure to an insecticide impacts the evolution of resistance to the herbicide glyphosate in Ipomoea purpurea (common morning glory). Through a factorial field experiment, we manipulated glyphosate and an insecticide to estimate selection on glyphosate and herbivory resistance. We found that glyphosate acted as the primary agent of selection, favoring higher levels of glyphosate resistance. In the presence of glyphosate alone, positive correlational selection favored a combination of higher glyphosate and herbivory resistance, supporting prior work that suggested these traits may be linked. Importantly, insecticide exposure modified both glyphosate resistance and the strength of selection acting upon the trait by increasing resistance and weakening selection. Together, our results indicate that the evolution of herbicide resistance is context-dependent and that secondary stressors like insecticide can alter the evolutionary trajectories of plant defense.

Avoiding fertilization with genetically incompatible partners, whether too similar or too divergent, is a central challenge for sexually reproducing organisms. Selection can favor mechanisms acting before and after mating, with postmating processes potentially compensating for constraints on premating choice. In the postmating context, female reproductive fluid (FRF) can modulate sperm performance and bias fertilization outcomes, but its contribution to reproductive isolation remains unclear. We tested whether FRF mediates discrimination against heterospecific and related sperm in two naturally hybridizing sister species of swordtails, Xiphophorus birchmanni and X. malinche, that diverge in premating behavior towards heterospecifics. Effects of FRF differed sharply between species. In X. malinche, FRF enhanced the velocity of conspecific sperm relative to heterospecifics, consistent with postmating discrimination against hybridization. In contrast, FRF in X. birchmanni did not favor conspecific sperm. Evidence for inbreeding avoidance was weaker, and we found no indication of a trade-off between discrimination against genetically similar and dissimilar sperm. These results show that female reproductive fluid can serve as a rapidly evolving axis of reproductive isolation through postmating female choice.

Parthenogenesis is relatively rare and often regarded as an evolutionary dead end. Despite this, certain parthenogenetic animal species have endured for millions of years, but it is unclear what enables the persistence of some parthenogenetic lineages. Transitions from sexual to parthenogenetic reproduction can occur through different evolutionary processes that give rise to diverse cytological reproductive mechanisms. These mechanisms are likely to influence genetic diversity, especially in the early stages after the transition to parthenogenesis and may thus affect lineage persistence. To understand such evolutionary transitions, we used experimental crosses to investigate the mechanism of parthenogenesis and the immediate genetic consequences of switching from sexual to parthenogenetic reproduction in the facultatively parthenogenetic phasmid Megacrania batesii. We obtained DNA sequence data from multiple lineages propagated over three generations via sex, parthenogenesis, or transitions between reproductive modes. We quantified heterozygosity and within-family genetic variation and compared the genetic patterns with predictions for known mechanisms of parthenogenesis. We found that a single generation of parthenogenesis typically resulted in (near-)complete loss of heterozygosity and an absence of within-family genetic variation, consistent with automixis with gamete duplication or terminal fusion and little/no recombination. However, we also found evidence of variation in the mechanism of parthenogenesis among lineages and even within the same individual, associated with drastic differences in the amount of heterozygosity and within-family genetic variation maintained across generations. Our findings show that considerable variation in parthenogenetic mechanisms can exist within populations and suggest that such variation could influence the persistence and evolution of parthenogenetic lineages.

Many simultaneous hermaphrodites use selfing for reproductive assurance only when outcrossing opportunities are limited, owing to inbreeding depression in selfed progeny. However, scenarios that enforce substantial selfing (such as during recolonisation) can rapidly select for a high selfing propensity, a shift in mating system that is expected to eliminate both inbreeding depression and the delayed reproductive onset under selfing that is typically associated with it. We tested these predictions in the flatworm Macrostomum hystrix, using a line derived from an outcrossing population that had been subjected to enforced selfing for multiple generations followed by several years of relaxed selection. As predicted, isolated individual forced to self and individuals with constant partner access (i.e. outcrossing opportunities) did not differ in reproductive onset nor in inbreeding depression estimated through offspring survival. However, a third treatment group that provided intermittent partner access (to allow outcrossing but minimise potential competition effects) showed a different pattern: no inbreeding depression in offspring but a substantially accelerated reproductive onset. Whilst our results thus support the effective purging of inbreeding depression and increased selfing propensity under enforced selfing, we suggest that cues of an unstable social or physical environment nevertheless exert a major influence on reproductive timing.

Theory suggests sexual selection will enhance population viability by purging deleterious alleles. However, direct genomic evidence for this fundamental idea is scarce and contradictory. We combined long-term experimental evolution with whole-genome re-sequencing to directly test how sexual selection affects mutation load, genomic divergence and extinction risk in Tribolium castaneum. After 156 generations, populations evolving under strong sexual selection carried substantially fewer deleterious alleles than populations under weak sexual selection, based on both individual-level estimates of missense and nonsense variants and population-level Rxy analyses, indicating more efficient purging of deleterious alleles. In contrast, nucleotide diversity and runs of homozygosity were similar across treatments, indicating that purging was targeted at deleterious variation, and that reduced mutation load in populations under strong sexual selection was not explained by demographic effects. Importantly, population-level mutation load estimates provided best explained extinction risk under inbreeding, directly linking sexual selection to purging and population viability for the first time. Genome scans of high and low sexual selection populations revealed peaks of divergence, enriched for genes involved in courtship, sex discrimination, and seminal fluid proteins. Our results provide direct genomic evidence that sexual selection can reduce mutation load without eroding standing genetic diversity and thus adaptive potential, while driving adaptive divergence in reproductive traits. This beneficial purging may help explain the widespread prevalence of sexual reproduction in nature despite inherent costs and have important ramifications as to how we manage populations of conservation concern. Significance StatementA long standing and unconfirmed prediction is that sexual selection can improve population health by biasing reproduction away from individuals with high deleterious mutation load. However, direct genomic evidence is lacking, and the indirect data available are scant and contradictory. Now, using whole-genome resequencing of experimental evolved beetle populations, we show that populations evolving under stronger sexual selection carry fewer deleterious mutations and, importantly, are less vulnerable to extinction. Our results provide the first direct genomic support for this long-debated evolutionary process that may help explain the widespread prevalence of sexual reproduction in nature. Our findings also highlight the importance of allowing sexual selection to act in populations of conservation concern.

Matching habitat choice provides a mechanism for individuals to maximise their expected fitness by selecting an environment that better fits their phenotype. Many animals choose their local environment by evaluating levels of perceived predation risk against possible resource gain. To test if predation risk is a major driver of habitat choice, we quantify scototaxis, or preference for dark versus light backgrounds, in juvenile guppies. As light backgrounds increase visibility to predators, this aspect of habitat choice captures variation in boldness in small fishes. By rearing and testing 586 fish descended from ten natural populations from Trinidad under common garden conditions, we first quantify (broad sense) heritable variation, i.e. evolutionary potential, within populations. Next, we test for evolutionary divergence among populations in mean preference, and if present, whether ancestral predation regime is a mediator of divergence. Finally, we ask whether families and/or populations differ in the amount of behavioural variation they contain. Habitat choice varied among families (12% of total variance), consistent with heritable variation (0.2). We also found mean preference varies among populations (11% of total variance explained). Evolutionary divergence among-populations is partly explained by ancestral predation regime, with populations from low-predation sites showing a stronger average preference for dark backgrounds than high-predation populations from the same river. Additionally, we find that within-population behavioural variation is greater in high-predation populations. We conclude that guppy populations contain heritable variation that could facilitate adaptive evolution if scototaxis is subject to natural selection. Furthermore, while genetic drift may also contribute to evolutionary divergence among-populations, observed patterns are qualitatively consistent with local adaption to predation regime. Our results suggests that high predation sites favour bolder habitat choice on average, but also that local predation regime shape the evolutionary dynamics of variation, perhaps by maintaining shy-bold variation among-individuals or by favouring individuals with less-predicable behaviour.

Adaptive radiation theory posits that speciation in such lineages is largely driven by ecological opportunity in concurrent morphological expansion in response to niche availability. Here, we use a phylogenomic estimate of Australasian diplodactyloid geckos in combination with meristic and ecological data to infer patterns of ecological diversification, quantify signatures of stabilizing selection, and the factors driving speciation processes. Specifically, we focus on two relatively young but speciose and ecomorphologically diverse assemblages from the ancient islands of New Caledonia and New Zealand. Models accounting for stabilizing selection recover shifts in morphospace along many branches that also experienced shifts in ecological guild as inferred from ancestral state reconstructions. We find convergent evolution to be present between the two insular lineages as they independently transitioned to similar guilds from different ancestral ecologies. Community assembly is integral to understanding the dynamics of adaptive radiations and various studies focused on identifying if biotic or abiotic factors drive character suits and sympatry in diverse lineages. Bayesian and multiple regression analyses suggest that abiotic factors rather than interspecific competition dictates phenotypic divergence in both insular lineages. Rather, species seem to diverge phenotypically in allopatry and environmental factors, such as climate, in combination with competitive exclusion drive phenotypic overlap in sympatry. This study provides the first modern assessment of convergence for diplodactyloid geckos and provides robust evidence indicating that similar selective pressures have shaped morphological diversity in these disparate as well the factors affecting sympatry.

Animal mating systems are hugely diverse, ranging from species where mating is essentially random to those exhibiting complex systems of mate choice by one or both sexes. While polygyny and mate choice are known to alter adaptation and persistence in a changing environment, there has been little exploration of the ways that adaptation and evolutionary rescue are modulated by other types of mating systems. We developed an individual-based model that allows random mating, female-only choice, and mutual mate choice to be compared between monogamous and polygynous frameworks and used it to explore how mating systems influence adaptive response, loss of heterozygosity, and extinction risk under worsening environmental conditions. We find that mating systems interact with population size in determining extinction risk: mate choice under polygyny lowers effective population size, small polygynous populations with either mutual or female-only mate choice lose heterozygosity quickly and so face higher extinction risks than randomly mating populations. However, in larger populations where inbreeding and genetic drift are less important, mate-choice-based polygynous systems enhance evolutionary rescue by allowing better-adapted males to dominate reproduction, accelerating adaptation and increasing resilience to environmental change. Among polygynous systems, female-only choice leads to slower loss of heterozygosity and facilitates population resilience better than mutual mate choice. These findings demonstrate that mating systems can critically shape a populations ability to adapt to environmental change and alter extinction risks, emphasizing the need to consider mating systems in designing effective conservation strategies. Significance StatementEnvironmental change threatens species survival, and sexual selection can have profound modulating processes that determine extinction risk. Sexual selection operates in a variety of mating systems, and the role of this diversity is often overlooked. Using individual-based simulations, we show that mating systems with mate choice boost evolutionary rescue in larger populations via "good genes," while in small populations, it has the opposite effect by elevating the loss of heterozygosity. These results have critical implications for conservation biology. Conservation strategies should consider mating system characteristics when assessing species vulnerability and planning management efforts to support evolutionary resilience and long-term population persistence.

Phenotypic plasticity allows plants to rapidly respond to changing environments without the need for evolutionary change or migration. While selection can create variation in plasticity across natural populations, these responses are not adaptive in all environments. To predict whether plasticity will be adaptive requires evaluation of its fitness effects across a range of environments, including novel ones. Here, we test how traits and their plasticity vary for genotypes collected across a natural hybrid zone between two tree species with contrasting climatic niches. Fast-growing Populus trichocarpa inhabits maritime environments with relatively warm and stable temperatures, while P. balsamifera inhabits continental environments with cold winters and large temperature variance throughout the year. We planted 44 clonally replicated genotypes into thirteen common gardens and measured vegetative phenology, leaf morphology, stomata morphology and conductance, and photochemistry. Overall, genotypes from colder, more continental environments exhibited higher plasticity. P. balsamifera ancestry was associated with increased plasticity in timing of fall phenology, stomatal conductance, and leaf mass per unit area. We assessed the effects of trait plasticity on fitness estimated as yearly growth across common gardens and found that the plasticity-fitness relationship was often garden-specific, indicating that the planting environment did not consistently mediate plasticity-fitness relationships. When the effects of trait plasticity on growth varied by garden temperature, higher plasticity generally had neutral or negative associations with growth in warmer environments. These results suggest that elevated plasticity evolved in a P. balsamifera genomic background as part of a climate generalist strategy to seasonal temperature variability, but that there is a trade-off between plasticity and growth in warmer environments. Consequently, less-plastic but warm-adapted P. trichocarpa genotypes are likely to have a fitness advantage under warming climates. These results demonstrate that plasticity may sometimes be maladaptive and will not be universally beneficial in a warming world.

Social interactions are ubiquitous in nature and have the potential to affect trait evolution, particularly in group-living animals such as cooperative breeders. Interactions among conspecific individuals can affect the amount of additive genetic variation for a trait when the phenotype of an individual is also affected by the genotype of its social partner(s) via indirect genetic effects. Thus, quantifying both direct and indirect genetic effects of social partners is critical for understanding and predicting evolutionary trajectories. While much is known about maternal indirect genetic effects, empirical estimates of indirect genetic effects from other social partners remain limited, particularly in wild populations. Here, we use animal models to assess the contribution of indirect genetic effects from all social partners in a family group (mothers, fathers, and helpers) on juvenile morphometric traits across ontogeny in the cooperatively-breeding Florida scrub-jay (Aphelocoma coerulescens). We found indirect genetic effects of helpers and fathers on nestling weight, but no indirect genetic effect of mothers. Across ontogeny, we found increasing additive genetic variation in both weight and tarsus length. Our study provides a comprehensive assessment of within-group indirect genetic effects in a cooperative breeder and highlights the importance of considering indirect genetic effects beyond maternal effects.

Parasites can alter host populations in fundamentally different ways depending on whether exposure results in infection. Yet, most epidemiological and evolutionary inference focuses on established infections, leaving the fitness consequences of parasite exposure comparatively understudied. This gap is consequential because hosts are frequently exposed to diverse parasite genotypes, and these encounters can impose substantial fitness costs even when infection does not occur. Theory predicts that hosts may mitigate these costs when interacting with commonly encountered parasite genotypes, such that exposure to sympatric parasites incurs lower fitness consequences than exposure to novel, allopatric parasites. Here, we examine the fitness consequences of exposure and infection in the first intermediate host of the trophically transmitted tapeworm Schistocephalus solidus, a cyclopoid copepod that serves as the first host in a three-host life cycle. Using sympatric (Vancouver Island, Canada) and allopatric (Norway) host-parasite combinations, we found a striking reciprocal asymmetry. Sympatric parasites were significantly more infective, yet exposure to sympatric parasites imposed weaker fitness costs when infection did not establish. In contrast, allopatric parasites were less infective, but exposed females produced fewer eggs and had lower hatching success than both controls and females exposed to sympatric parasites, indicating substantial genotype-dependent costs of exposure. Moreover, we found that infection was highly virulent across all genotypes: a single parasite caused near-complete reproductive suppression and reduced host survival across all host-parasite pairings, confirming S. solidus as a castrating parasite in copepods. Together, these results demonstrate that exposure, not just infection, acts as a critical ecological filter with potentially large and underappreciated consequences for host population dynamics and parasite transmission.

Population-specific immunity can drive variation in infection outcomes, but studying immune variation in the wild is challenging because exposure histories are unknown. Comparing wild populations with those reared in a common environment can disentangle genetic and environmental drivers of immunity. We applied this approach in freshwater threespine stickleback, where populations vary in their use of intraperitoneal fibrosis to defend against the helminth parasite Schistocephalus solidus. We combined a 46-lake immune survey with a common garden experiment using 20 representative populations to examine variation in fibrosis and infection. Laboratory assays included exposures to live tapeworms and immune challenges with tapeworm proteins and aluminum phosphate (Alum). We found heritable variation in both constitutive fibrosis and inducible fibrosis. Inducible responses to tapeworms were associated with lake environmental conditions, with fish from more eutrophic-like lakes showing stronger fibrosis induction than those from more oligotrophic-like lakes. Together, these results show how integrating wild immune variation with common garden experiments can reveal novel heritable defenses and link their evolution to ecological variation.